Types of Manuscript

Malaqbi Law Review (MLR) is a peer-reviewed scientific journal published by Sekolah Tinggi Agama Islam Negeri (STAIN) Majene, West Sulawesi, Indonesia. The journal publishes original scholarly works that contribute to the advancement of legal knowledge, constitutional studies, and the development of legal practices at national and international levels.

MLR welcomes manuscripts addressing a broad range of legal disciplines, including general legal studies, comparative law, legal theory, constitutional law, administrative law, customary law, Islamic law, philosophy of law, criminal law, civil and private law, international law, business and banking law, environmental law, cyber law, and human rights. The journal also encourages scholarly discussions on law and democracy, political law, political parties, electoral systems, parliamentary institutions, government systems, public policies, and contemporary developments in legal and constitutional affairs.

Malaqbi Law Review accepts original research articles and conceptual scholarly works developed through appropriate legal research methodologies and analytical approaches. All manuscripts are expected to demonstrate academic rigor, originality, critical legal reasoning, and meaningful contributions to the development of legal scholarship and constitutional practice.

The journal considers the following types of manuscripts:

1. NORMATIVE AND DOCTRINAL LEGAL RESEARCH ARTICLES

These manuscripts present original scholarly investigations examining legal norms, principles, doctrines, regulations, and authoritative legal materials. They focus on the interpretation, construction, application, and development of law through systematic legal reasoning and critical examination of existing legal frameworks.

Authors may employ statutory, conceptual, case-based, historical, and analytical approaches to examine legal problems and develop arguments concerning the consistency, effectiveness, and adequacy of legal provisions and doctrines.

Relevant subjects include constitutional law, administrative law, criminal law, civil law, private law, Islamic law, customary law, international law, business and banking law, environmental law, cyber law, and human rights. Research examining legislation, constitutional court decisions, judicial reasoning, legal principles, and regulatory frameworks is also included in this category.

2. EMPIRICAL AND SOCIO-LEGAL RESEARCH ARTICLES

These manuscripts investigate the relationship between law and society by examining how legal norms, regulations, institutions, and public policies operate in practical settings. They explore the implementation, effectiveness, and social implications of legal rules, as well as the experiences and perspectives of individuals, communities, government institutions, and other relevant stakeholders.

Suitable approaches include qualitative, quantitative, and mixed-methods research. Data may be obtained through interviews, surveys, observations, field studies, institutional records, case documentation, and other relevant empirical sources.

Relevant topics include law enforcement, access to justice, human rights protection, public administration, electoral practices, political party activities, democratic governance, environmental regulation, customary legal practices, Islamic law in society, and the implementation of public policies.

Manuscripts in this category must demonstrate an appropriate research design, transparent data collection procedures, systematic analysis, and meaningful interpretations of empirical findings. Research involving human participants must comply with applicable research ethics requirements.

3. COMPARATIVE LEGAL RESEARCH ARTICLES

These manuscripts examine similarities and differences between legal systems, constitutional arrangements, legislative frameworks, judicial institutions, and legal practices across different countries, jurisdictions, or institutional contexts.

Comparative legal studies may investigate how different legal systems address similar legal problems, how legal institutions develop across jurisdictions, or how international legal principles influence domestic legislation and governance.

Relevant subjects include comparative constitutional law, comparative administrative law, international law, electoral systems, judicial institutions, human rights protection, Islamic legal systems, environmental regulations, and comparative approaches to criminal and civil justice.

Authors must provide a clear comparative framework, identify the legal and institutional contexts being examined, and explain the significance of the comparison. The analysis should go beyond describing differences and similarities by offering critical insights into legal development, institutional effectiveness, or possible legal reforms.

4. CONCEPTUAL, THEORETICAL, AND INTERDISCIPLINARY LEGAL ARTICLES

These manuscripts develop original scholarly arguments, theoretical perspectives, conceptual frameworks, or critical interpretations addressing contemporary legal and constitutional issues. They may examine established legal theories, evaluate existing legal doctrines, propose alternative legal approaches, or discuss emerging challenges in the development of law and governance.

The journal also welcomes interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary studies that connect legal scholarship with other academic fields, including political science, economics, sociology, public administration, Islamic studies, philosophy, technology, and environmental studies.

Relevant discussions may include law and democracy, political constitution, government systems, public policy, political parties, electoral institutions, parliamentary relations, legal philosophy, Islamic legal thought, environmental governance, digital transformation, artificial intelligence and law, and other emerging legal issues.

Conceptual and theoretical manuscripts must present coherent academic arguments, demonstrate critical engagement with relevant scholarly literature and legal sources, and identify their original contribution to the development of legal knowledge. Purely descriptive discussions without sufficient analytical depth or scholarly contribution will not be considered suitable for publication.

GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR ALL MANUSCRIPTS

Regardless of the manuscript category, all submissions must satisfy the following requirements:

  • Address legal issues that fall within the focus and scope of Malaqbi Law Review.
  • Present original scholarly contributions supported by relevant legal materials and academic references.
  • Demonstrate a clearly identified research problem, appropriate methodology or analytical framework, and well-supported conclusions.
  • Apply rigorous legal reasoning, critical analysis, and appropriate interpretation of relevant legal sources.
  • Use reliable, relevant, and sufficiently up-to-date references, including primary legal materials where appropriate.
  • Comply with the journal's authorship requirements, research ethics, publication ethics, and other editorial policies.
  • Follow the official Malaqbi Law Review Author Guidelines and Manuscript Template.

All manuscripts must constitute original scholarly works that have not been previously published and are not simultaneously under consideration by another journal or publication outlet. Submissions must undergo an initial editorial screening before proceeding to the peer-review process.

Manuscripts that fall outside the journal's focus and scope, lack sufficient originality or scholarly contribution, or substantially fail to comply with the journal's submission requirements may be returned to the authors or rejected at the initial editorial screening stage.

Authors are strongly encouraged to consult the following documents before submitting their manuscripts:

Author Guidelines

Official Manuscript Template