REVIEWER GUIDELINES

Malaqbi Law Review (MLR) is committed to maintaining high standards of academic quality and publication ethics through a rigorous peer-review process. Reviewers play an essential role in evaluating the quality, originality, relevance, and scholarly contribution of submitted manuscripts. Their assessments assist the Editorial Board in making informed editorial decisions and help authors improve the quality of their scholarly work.

MLR applies a double-blind peer-review system, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are kept confidential throughout the review process. Reviewers are expected to conduct their evaluations objectively, independently, fairly, and professionally.

1. Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers are expected to:

  1. Evaluate manuscripts objectively and independently based on their academic quality, originality, relevance, and contribution to legal scholarship.

  2. Maintain strict confidentiality regarding all manuscripts and information received during the review process.

  3. Provide constructive, clear, and evidence-based comments to help authors improve their manuscripts.

  4. Identify relevant published works that have not been appropriately cited by the authors.

  5. Notify the Editorial Board of any suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, citation manipulation, or other forms of research misconduct.

  6. Disclose any potential conflicts of interest that may affect their impartiality.

  7. Complete their reviews within the period agreed upon with the Editorial Board.

  8. Refrain from using unpublished manuscript content, ideas, arguments, or research findings for personal or professional advantage.

2. Reviewer Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers are requested to assess submitted manuscripts based on the following criteria:

A. Relevance and Scope

  • The manuscript is relevant to the focus and scope of Malaqbi Law Review, particularly in legal studies and constitutional studies.

  • The topic addresses significant legal issues and demonstrates relevance to contemporary developments in law.

B. Originality and Contribution

  • The manuscript presents original scholarly work and demonstrates a clear research contribution.

  • The research problem, objectives, and novelty are clearly identified.

  • The manuscript provides meaningful contributions to the development of legal knowledge and scholarship.

C. Literature Review and Legal References

  • The manuscript demonstrates an adequate understanding of relevant legal theories, concepts, and previous research.

  • References include relevant primary and secondary legal sources.

  • Legal regulations, court decisions, and other authoritative materials are appropriately cited and sufficiently updated where relevant.

D. Research Methodology

  • The research method is appropriate to the research objectives and problems.

  • The methodology is explained clearly and systematically.

  • The sources of legal materials or research data and the methods of analysis are adequately described.

E. Legal Analysis and Discussion

  • The analysis demonstrates logical reasoning, critical thinking, and sufficient academic depth.

  • Legal arguments are supported by relevant theories, legal provisions, jurisprudence, and scholarly references.

  • The discussion addresses the research questions and objectives rather than merely describing legal concepts or regulations.

F. Conclusions and Implications

  • The conclusions are consistent with the research findings and discussion.

  • The manuscript explains its academic, theoretical, or practical contributions.

  • Recommendations, where applicable, are relevant and logically supported.

G. Structure, Language, and Referencing

  • The manuscript follows the official Malaqbi Law Review manuscript template and author guidelines.

  • The article is organized coherently and written in clear academic Indonesian or English.

  • Citations and references are presented consistently and in accordance with the journal's prescribed referencing guidelines.

3. Ethical Responsibilities and Confidentiality

Reviewers must respect the confidentiality of the double-blind peer-review process. Manuscripts assigned for review must not be shared, reproduced, distributed, or discussed with unauthorized individuals.

Reviewers must not attempt to identify the authors or disclose their own identities to the authors. Any communication concerning the manuscript must be conducted through the Editorial Board or the official journal system.

Reviewers must also avoid using any unpublished information obtained through the review process for personal research, publication, or other professional purposes without the author's explicit permission.

If reviewers suspect plagiarism, duplicate submission, falsification, fabrication, or other potential ethical violations, they must confidentially notify the Editorial Board and provide relevant supporting information.

4. Conflict of Interest

Reviewers must disclose any actual or potential conflict of interest before accepting a review assignment or as soon as such a conflict becomes apparent.

Conflicts of interest may include, but are not limited to:

  • Personal, professional, or financial relationships with the authors.

  • Current or recent institutional affiliations that may compromise impartiality.

  • Previous collaborations, joint publications, or supervisory relationships with the authors.

  • Academic or professional competition that may influence the reviewer's judgment.

  • Any other circumstances that could reasonably affect the objectivity of the evaluation.

When a conflict of interest exists, reviewers should decline the assignment or immediately inform the Editorial Board so that appropriate arrangements can be made.

5. Review Recommendations

After completing the evaluation, reviewers are expected to provide a clear recommendation to the Editorial Board. The recommendations may include:

A. Accept

The manuscript meets the journal's academic and editorial standards and requires no substantial revisions.

B. Minor Revisions

The manuscript is potentially suitable for publication but requires limited revisions, clarifications, or improvements.

C. Major Revisions

The manuscript requires substantial improvements in its argumentation, methodology, literature review, analysis, or presentation before it can be reconsidered.

D. Reject

The manuscript does not meet the journal's academic standards, falls outside the journal's scope, lacks sufficient originality or scholarly contribution, or contains fundamental weaknesses that cannot reasonably be addressed through revision.

Reviewers must provide supporting explanations for their recommendations. The final decision regarding manuscript acceptance, revision, or rejection rests solely with the Editorial Board, taking into consideration the reviewers' reports and the journal's editorial policies.

6. Submission of Review Reports

Reviewers are requested to submit their evaluation reports through the official Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform or other communication channels designated by the Editorial Board.

Review reports should contain:

  1. A general assessment of the manuscript's strengths and weaknesses.

  2. Specific comments and recommendations for improving the manuscript.

  3. Identification of substantial academic, methodological, or ethical concerns, where applicable.

  4. A clear recommendation regarding the editorial decision.

Comments should be professional, respectful, constructive, and sufficiently detailed to help authors understand the required improvements.

Reviewers may provide confidential comments to the Editor separately from comments intended for the authors.

7. Commitment to Publication Ethics

Malaqbi Law Review expects all reviewers to uphold the principles of academic integrity, fairness, confidentiality, and professional responsibility throughout the peer-review process.

By accepting a review assignment, reviewers acknowledge their responsibility to provide an honest and impartial evaluation that supports the quality and integrity of scholarly publishing.

MLR adheres to recognized publication ethics principles, including the ethical guidelines established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

For further information or inquiries regarding the peer-review process, reviewers may contact the Editorial Office of Malaqbi Law Review at:

Email: malaqbilawreview@stainmajene.ac.id

Website: https://jurnal.stainmajene.ac.id/index.php/malaju