Research Misconduct

Malaqbi Law Review (MLR) is committed to maintaining academic integrity, research credibility, and ethical standards throughout the scholarly publishing process. The journal considers research misconduct a serious violation of academic principles that may undermine the reliability of legal scholarship and the trustworthiness of published academic works.

Research misconduct refers to intentional or serious violations of accepted standards of research and publication integrity, including fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, citation manipulation, redundant publication, authorship manipulation, and other unethical practices in conducting, reviewing, or reporting scholarly research.

In legal scholarship, such misconduct may also involve fabricating interview findings, manipulating legal research materials, misrepresenting statutory provisions or judicial decisions, presenting inaccurate quotations from authoritative legal sources, or deliberately omitting relevant information to create misleading legal arguments.

Malaqbi Law Review takes all allegations of research misconduct seriously and is committed to addressing them through fair, confidential, and impartial procedures. The Editorial Board may refer to recognized publication ethics standards, including the guidelines and flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), when assessing and resolving suspected misconduct.

1. TYPES OF RESEARCH MISCONDUCT

The following practices are considered forms of research or publication misconduct and may result in editorial or ethical action:

  • Fabrication: Inventing research data, interview results, survey responses, observations, legal evidence, or other research materials and presenting them as genuine findings.
  • Falsification: Manipulating, altering, misrepresenting, or selectively omitting research data, legal documents, statutory provisions, judicial decisions, or other scholarly materials in a manner that misleads readers.
  • Plagiarism: Using another person's ideas, arguments, language, research findings, or intellectual contributions without appropriate acknowledgment or citation.
  • Citation Manipulation: Deliberately manipulating references, quotations, or citation practices to create misleading impressions of scholarly support, relevance, or academic influence.
  • Duplicate or Redundant Publication: Submitting or publishing substantially similar research in multiple journals without appropriate disclosure, authorization, or justification.
  • Authorship Misconduct: Falsely claiming authorship, excluding individuals who have made substantial scholarly contributions, adding individuals without legitimate contributions, or manipulating author identities and affiliations.
  • Peer-Review Manipulation: Providing false reviewer identities, manipulating reviewer recommendations, interfering with the independence of reviewers, or attempting to improperly influence editorial decisions.
  • Other Unethical Research Practices: Conducting or reporting research in violation of applicable ethical requirements, misusing confidential information, or engaging in other practices that seriously undermine the integrity and reliability of scholarly work.

2. HANDLING ALLEGATIONS OF RESEARCH MISCONDUCT

Any individual who identifies suspected research misconduct involving a manuscript submitted to or published in Malaqbi Law Review may report the matter to the Editorial Board through the journal's official communication channels. Allegations should, whenever possible, be accompanied by relevant information or supporting evidence to facilitate an appropriate assessment.

Upon receiving an allegation, the Editorial Board will undertake an initial assessment to determine whether the concern is sufficiently credible and falls within the scope of research or publication misconduct. The assessment will also consider the credibility of the available evidence and whether the allegation itself may involve any relevant conflicts of interest.

Where there are reasonable grounds for concern, the journal may undertake the following procedures:

  1. Preliminary Assessment: The Editorial Board examines the allegation and available evidence to determine its relevance and seriousness.
  2. Author Notification: The corresponding author is informed of the concern and given an appropriate opportunity to provide a written explanation and supporting documentation on behalf of the authors.
  3. Further Examination: The Editorial Board evaluates the author's response and may seek additional clarification, consult independent academic experts, or request assistance from relevant institutions when necessary.
  4. Editorial Evaluation: Based on the available evidence and responses, the Editorial Board determines whether misconduct has occurred and identifies appropriate measures.
  5. Resolution and Follow-up: The journal takes proportionate action in accordance with the seriousness of the case and applicable publication ethics standards.

Throughout the investigation, the journal will make reasonable efforts to maintain confidentiality, protect the rights of the parties involved, and avoid premature conclusions. Authors must be given a fair opportunity to respond to allegations before a final editorial determination is made, except in circumstances where immediate protective action is necessary to safeguard the integrity of the publication record.

Where appropriate, the Editorial Board may contact the author's affiliated institution or other relevant authorities to request further investigation or verification. Institutional findings may be considered alongside the journal's own editorial assessment.

3. EDITORIAL ACTIONS AND SANCTIONS

The action taken by Malaqbi Law Review depends on the nature, severity, and timing of the identified misconduct.

A. Before Publication

If a submitted manuscript is found to contain substantiated research misconduct, the journal may reject the manuscript and discontinue its editorial processing. Depending on the circumstances, the Editorial Board may also request corrections, additional explanations, or supporting documentation before reaching a decision.

B. After Publication

If misconduct is identified after an article has been published, the Editorial Board will assess the effect of the misconduct on the reliability, originality, and integrity of the published work. Depending on the findings, the journal may issue a correction, publish an expression of concern, or retract the article.

C. Institutional Notification

In serious cases, the journal may notify the relevant institution or affiliated organization and provide available evidence to support further examination. Any communication with institutions will be handled with due consideration for confidentiality and procedural fairness.

4. RETRACTION POLICY

Malaqbi Law Review may consider retracting a published article when substantial evidence demonstrates that the publication is unreliable, seriously misleading, or violates fundamental principles of academic integrity.

Grounds for retraction may include, but are not limited to:

  • Clear evidence of fabricated or falsified research data, documents, or findings.
  • Substantial plagiarism or unauthorized use of another person's intellectual work.
  • Redundant or duplicate publication without proper disclosure or justification.
  • Serious manipulation or misrepresentation of legal sources, research materials, or scholarly findings that undermines the validity of the article.
  • Evidence that the research was conducted or reported in violation of fundamental ethical requirements.
  • Manipulation of the peer-review or publication process that compromises the legitimacy of the editorial decision.
  • Undisclosed competing interests that materially affect the reliability or interpretation of the published work.
  • Other serious circumstances that substantially undermine the credibility or integrity of the scholarly record.

A retraction will be accompanied by a formal retraction notice explaining the reason for the action. The notice will identify the affected article and, wherever possible, provide a direct link to the original publication.

The original article will remain identifiable in the journal's publication record and will be clearly marked as retracted, subject to applicable legal and technical requirements. Retraction notices will be made publicly accessible to ensure transparency and prevent readers from relying on unreliable scholarly findings.

The journal distinguishes retraction from correction. Minor errors that do not substantially affect the validity, interpretation, or reliability of an article may be addressed through a correction notice rather than retraction.

5. CORRECTIONS AND EXPRESSION OF CONCERN

Not every identified error or irregularity necessarily constitutes research misconduct or requires retraction. Where an article contains an error that can be corrected without compromising its overall scholarly validity, the Editorial Board may issue a correction notice and update the relevant publication record.

When credible concerns arise but the available evidence is insufficient to establish whether serious misconduct has occurred, the journal may publish an expression of concern to inform readers while further examination is undertaken.

These measures are intended to protect the accuracy and reliability of the academic record while ensuring that editorial actions remain proportionate to the circumstances of each case.

6. COMMITMENT TO RESEARCH INTEGRITY

Malaqbi Law Review recognizes that authors, editors, reviewers, institutions, and publishers share responsibility for maintaining the integrity of academic scholarship. All parties are expected to uphold honesty, transparency, accountability, and respect for intellectual contributions throughout the research and publication process.

The journal's handling of research misconduct allegations and retraction decisions is informed by recognized publication ethics guidance, particularly the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Retraction Guidelines.

For further information, readers and authors may consult the following resource:

Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) – Retraction Guidelines:
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.4