Conflict of Interest

Malaqbi Law Review (MLR) is committed to upholding transparency, impartiality, and academic integrity throughout the manuscript submission, evaluation, and publication processes. All authors, editors, and reviewers are required to disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, the research process, manuscript evaluation, or editorial decisions.

A conflict of interest may arise when personal, financial, professional, institutional, or other relationships interfere with an individual's ability to make objective and independent academic judgments. The disclosure and appropriate management of such interests are essential to maintaining the credibility and fairness of scholarly publishing.

1. AUTHORS

Authors must disclose all financial and non-financial interests that may have influenced the research, legal analysis, interpretation of findings, or preparation of the manuscript. Such interests may include, but are not limited to:

  • Employment, consultancy, professional appointments, honoraria, or financial relationships with organizations relevant to the research.
  • Research grants, institutional funding, sponsorship, or other financial support related to the submitted manuscript.
  • Personal, family, professional, or institutional relationships that may affect the objectivity of the research.
  • Involvement in legal proceedings, advocacy activities, litigation, or professional representation connected to the subject under investigation.
  • Affiliations with government institutions, political organizations, law firms, corporations, or other entities whose interests may be affected by the research findings.
  • Intellectual property rights, ownership interests, or other competing professional interests relevant to the manuscript.

In particular, authors conducting research on legal institutions, public policies, judicial decisions, legislation, or regulatory practices should disclose any relevant professional or institutional involvement that could reasonably influence their analysis or conclusions.

All sources of financial support must be clearly acknowledged in the manuscript. Authors are responsible for ensuring that their conflict-of-interest declarations are accurate, complete, and transparent.

If no competing interests exist, authors should include the following statement in their manuscript:

"The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest."

Where a conflict of interest exists, authors must provide a clear explanation of its nature and disclose any relevant measures taken to manage or minimize its potential influence on the research.

2. EDITORS

Editors of Malaqbi Law Review must maintain independence, fairness, and objectivity when handling submitted manuscripts. Any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest involving a manuscript must be disclosed to the Editorial Board as soon as it is identified.

An editor who has a conflict of interest must not participate in the assessment, reviewer selection, editorial discussion, or final decision-making process concerning the manuscript. In such circumstances, the manuscript must be assigned to another qualified and independent editor who can manage the evaluation impartially.

Manuscripts submitted by members of the Editorial Board, journal staff, or individuals with close professional or institutional relationships with the handling editor must undergo an independent editorial arrangement. Such submissions remain subject to the same academic standards and peer-review requirements applied to other manuscripts.

Editors must also preserve the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and must not use unpublished information, research findings, or ideas obtained through their editorial responsibilities for personal, academic, or professional benefit without the appropriate authorization of the authors.

3. REVIEWERS

Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts independently and disclose any circumstances that may compromise, or reasonably appear to compromise, their impartiality. Such circumstances may include:

  • Financial interests or professional arrangements involving the authors or organizations associated with the manuscript.
  • Current or recent research collaborations, joint publications, or other close academic relationships with the authors.
  • Shared institutional affiliations or professional appointments that may affect objective assessment.
  • Personal relationships, disagreements, or academic rivalries that could influence the reviewer's judgment.
  • Involvement in legal cases, policy matters, or research projects directly related to the manuscript under review.
  • Current or previous supervisory, mentoring, or other professional relationships with the authors.

Reviewers who identify a potential conflict of interest must promptly inform the Editorial Board and decline the review assignment or withdraw from the evaluation when appropriate. The Editorial Board will arrange an alternative reviewer to ensure the fairness and independence of the review process.

Reviewers are strictly required to maintain manuscript confidentiality. Information, arguments, legal analysis, or unpublished research findings obtained during the review process must not be used for personal or professional advantage.

4. EDITORIAL MANAGEMENT AND DISCLOSURE PROCEDURES

Malaqbi Law Review ensures that editorial decisions are based on the scholarly merit, originality, relevance, methodological soundness, and contribution of submitted manuscripts to the development of legal scholarship. Decisions must remain independent of personal relationships, institutional interests, competing professional activities, or other external influences.

The Editorial Board is responsible for reviewing disclosed conflicts of interest and determining appropriate measures to prevent or minimize their influence. Depending on the circumstances, such measures may include:

  • Reassigning a manuscript to an independent editor.
  • Appointing alternative reviewers without conflicting interests.
  • Requesting additional declarations or clarification from the individuals concerned.
  • Ensuring appropriate disclosure of relevant competing interests in the published article, where necessary.
  • Conducting further ethical investigation when a significant undisclosed conflict is identified.

Any failure to disclose a relevant conflict of interest, or the submission of inaccurate or misleading declarations, may result in further investigation and appropriate editorial action in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies.

Conflicts of interest identified after publication will also be evaluated by the Editorial Board. Where necessary, the journal may issue an appropriate disclosure, correction, expression of concern, or retraction in accordance with the seriousness of the matter and applicable publication ethics standards.

By submitting a manuscript to Malaqbi Law Review, authors, editors, and reviewers acknowledge their responsibility to disclose relevant competing interests honestly and cooperate with the journal in maintaining a transparent, fair, and ethically responsible publication process.