Correction and Retraction

Malaqbi Law Review (MLR) is committed to preserving the accuracy, transparency, and integrity of the scholarly record. The journal recognizes that, on certain occasions, errors or ethical concerns may be identified after an article has been formally published. Such matters must be addressed appropriately to ensure that readers, researchers, legal practitioners, and other members of the academic community can rely on the information presented in the journal.

To maintain the credibility of its publications, MLR establishes procedures for issuing corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions when necessary. These procedures are intended to ensure that any changes to published articles are handled responsibly, transparently, and in accordance with recognized publication ethics standards, particularly the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

1. CORRECTION OF PUBLISHED ARTICLES

A correction may be issued when an error is identified in a published article and the error requires clarification or amendment without fundamentally undermining the reliability of the research, legal analysis, or conclusions.

Corrections may be considered in circumstances involving:

  • Incorrect information, typographical errors, or factual inaccuracies that may cause misunderstanding among readers.
  • Errors in author names, institutional affiliations, acknowledgments, or other publication details.
  • Incorrect citations, references, or bibliographic information that require amendment.
  • Errors in tables, figures, legal quotations, statutory references, or other research materials that do not invalidate the overall scholarly contribution.
  • Unintentional omissions or inaccuracies in the published text that require clarification.
  • Other limited errors that can be rectified without compromising the overall validity and integrity of the article.

Requests for corrections may be submitted by the authors, readers, reviewers, or other parties who identify a relevant error in a published article. All requests must provide sufficient information to identify the article and explain the nature of the proposed correction.

The Editorial Board will assess each request and may consult the authors, reviewers, or independent academic experts when necessary. If a correction is considered appropriate, MLR will publish a formal correction notice describing the error and the corresponding amendment.

The correction notice will be linked to the original article to ensure that readers can identify the changes made to the published record. The journal will maintain transparency regarding the correction rather than making substantial changes to published content without an appropriate notification.

2. EXPRESSION OF CONCERN

An Expression of Concern may be issued when credible information indicates that a published article may contain serious problems, but the available evidence is not yet sufficient to establish whether correction or retraction is necessary.

This measure may be considered in situations involving:

  • Ongoing investigations into suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, or other forms of research misconduct.
  • Unresolved questions concerning the validity or reliability of the research findings or legal arguments presented in the article.
  • Concerns regarding research ethics, authorship, or undisclosed conflicts of interest that require further examination.
  • Delays in obtaining essential information or verification from the authors or their affiliated institutions.
  • Other circumstances in which notifying readers of a potential problem is necessary while an investigation remains ongoing.

An Expression of Concern serves as a temporary notification to readers and does not constitute a final determination that misconduct has occurred. The Editorial Board will continue examining the matter and may subsequently issue a correction, proceed with retraction, or withdraw the Expression of Concern if the available evidence does not support further action.

3. RETRACTION OF PUBLISHED ARTICLES

Retraction is a formal editorial action taken when a published article is found to contain serious problems that substantially undermine the reliability, originality, ethical validity, or integrity of its scholarly contribution.

Malaqbi Law Review may consider retracting an article under circumstances including, but not limited to:

  • Unreliable Findings: Clear evidence that the research findings, legal analysis, or conclusions are unreliable due to serious errors, data fabrication, falsification, or other substantial inaccuracies.
  • Plagiarism: Substantial unauthorized use or reproduction of another person's intellectual work without appropriate acknowledgment.
  • Duplicate or Redundant Publication: Evidence that the article has been published elsewhere without proper disclosure, authorization, or an acceptable scholarly justification.
  • Unethical Research Practices: Serious violations of applicable research ethics requirements that compromise the legitimacy or reliability of the published work.
  • Manipulation of the Publication Process: Evidence of fraudulent authorship, manipulated peer review, fabricated reviewer identities, or other practices that undermine the integrity of editorial evaluation.
  • Misrepresentation of Legal Materials: Serious fabrication, falsification, or deliberate misrepresentation of legislation, judicial decisions, legal evidence, research materials, or other authoritative sources that invalidates the article's principal arguments or conclusions.
  • Undisclosed Competing Interests: Failure to disclose a significant conflict of interest that materially compromises the interpretation, credibility, or recommendations presented in the article.
  • Other Serious Ethical Violations: Other circumstances in which the published article can no longer be considered a reliable and trustworthy part of the scholarly record.

Retraction is intended to correct the academic record and protect readers from relying on unreliable publications. It is not primarily intended as a punitive measure against authors. The decision must be based on the available evidence, the seriousness of the concern, and the extent to which the published work is affected.

4. PROCEDURES FOR CORRECTION AND RETRACTION

Malaqbi Law Review applies a fair and transparent assessment process when considering requests for corrections or allegations that may result in the retraction of a published article.

The procedures generally include the following stages:

  1. Submission of a Request or Allegation: Authors, readers, institutions, or other concerned parties may report an error or suspected problem by contacting the Editorial Board through the journal's official communication channels. The report should identify the affected article and provide a clear explanation and supporting evidence.
  2. Initial Editorial Assessment: The Editorial Board examines the information received to determine the nature, credibility, and potential impact of the reported issue.
  3. Author Notification and Response: When appropriate, the corresponding author is informed of the concern and given a reasonable opportunity to provide an explanation, clarification, or relevant supporting documentation.
  4. Further Examination: The Editorial Board may consult independent experts, seek clarification from the authors, or communicate with relevant institutions or research organizations to establish the facts.
  5. Editorial Decision: After reviewing the available evidence and responses, the Editorial Board determines whether a correction, Expression of Concern, or retraction is the appropriate course of action.
  6. Publication of the Notice: Where an editorial action is necessary, MLR publishes an appropriate notice and links it to the affected article to maintain transparency and preserve the accuracy of the publication record.

All assessments must be conducted objectively and confidentially, with due consideration for the rights and responsibilities of the parties involved. The final editorial decision rests with the Editorial Board, independently of any financial, personal, or institutional interests.

5. RETRACTION NOTICE AND PRESERVATION OF THE PUBLISHED RECORD

When an article is retracted, Malaqbi Law Review will publish a formal retraction notice that is freely accessible to readers and directly connected to the original publication wherever technically possible.

A retraction notice should contain the following information:

  • The title and author information of the affected article.
  • The original publication details, including the journal issue, publication year, and DOI or article URL, where available.
  • A clear explanation of the reason for retraction.
  • Identification of the party or authority responsible for the retraction decision.
  • The date on which the retraction notice is issued.

The original article will generally remain accessible in the journal's archive but will be clearly identified as retracted. Its retracted status must be visible to readers to prevent the article from being mistaken for an active and reliable publication.

The journal will not remove or silently replace a retracted article merely to conceal its previous publication history. Removal may only be considered in exceptional circumstances, such as serious legal requirements, risks to personal safety, privacy violations, or other circumstances that justify restricting public access. Any such action must be appropriately documented while maintaining a transparent publication record to the extent permitted.

6. RESPONSIBILITIES OF AUTHORS AND THE EDITORIAL BOARD

Authors are responsible for ensuring the accuracy, originality, and integrity of their published work. If an author discovers a significant error after publication, they are expected to notify the Editorial Board promptly and cooperate in the correction or retraction process when necessary.

The Editorial Board is responsible for evaluating reported concerns independently, communicating relevant findings to the parties involved, and taking proportionate action to protect the scholarly record.

All parties are expected to cooperate in good faith and provide accurate information during the evaluation process. The journal will not tolerate attempts to obstruct investigations, conceal relevant evidence, or improperly influence editorial decisions.

7. ETHICAL GUIDANCE AND REFERENCE

Malaqbi Law Review follows recognized publication ethics principles in addressing corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions. The journal refers particularly to the guidance issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), including its Retraction Guidelines.

For additional information regarding international standards for correcting and retracting published scholarly works, readers and authors may consult the following official resource:

Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) – Retraction Guidelines, Version 3 (August 2025)
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.4

Through this policy, Malaqbi Law Review seeks to uphold the reliability of published legal scholarship, protect the interests of readers and researchers, and maintain public confidence in the academic publication process.