Authorship Criteria

Malaqbi Law Review (MLR) regards authorship as both an academic recognition and a responsibility that reflects an individual's substantial intellectual contribution to scholarly research. Every person listed as an author must have made a meaningful contribution to the development of the manuscript and must be willing to take responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of the published work.

Authorship must not be granted solely on the basis of academic position, institutional affiliation, professional seniority, financial support, administrative involvement, or general supervision. All listed authors are expected to satisfy the journal's authorship requirements to ensure proper attribution and accountability in academic publishing.

1. CRITERIA FOR AUTHORSHIP

To qualify for authorship in Malaqbi Law Review, each individual must fulfill all of the following four criteria:

  • Substantial Intellectual Contribution: The individual must have made a significant contribution to the conception or design of the research, the development of its legal or theoretical framework, the collection of research materials, or the analysis and interpretation of legal sources, empirical findings, or other relevant research evidence.
  • Manuscript Preparation and Critical Revision: The individual must have participated in drafting the manuscript or critically revising it to improve its substantial academic and intellectual content, including legal arguments, theoretical analysis, research methodology, and scholarly interpretation.
  • Final Manuscript Approval: The individual must review and approve the final version of the manuscript before it is submitted for publication, including any substantial revisions made during the editorial and peer-review process.
  • Accountability for Scholarly Work: The individual must agree to be accountable for their own contributions and cooperate in addressing any questions concerning the accuracy, originality, validity, or ethical integrity of the research.

Individuals who have made substantial intellectual contributions to the research should be given an appropriate opportunity to participate in manuscript drafting or critical revision and final approval so that they may fulfill the remaining authorship requirements.

2. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

All authors are expected to contribute meaningfully to the research and preparation of the manuscript. Their respective roles and responsibilities must be accurately represented and should reflect the actual work performed throughout the research and writing process.

Malaqbi Law Review encourages authors to provide transparent descriptions of individual contributions. Where appropriate, authors may use the Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT) to identify their respective contributions, including:

  • Conceptualization: Development of the research questions, objectives, and overall scholarly direction.
  • Methodology: Development of the research design, legal research approach, and analytical procedures.
  • Investigation: Conducting legal research, gathering legal materials, collecting empirical evidence, and examining relevant documents.
  • Formal Analysis: Conducting substantive legal analysis, interpreting research findings, and evaluating relevant legal theories and principles.
  • Data Curation: Organizing and managing research materials, legal documents, case records, interview transcripts, and other relevant evidence.
  • Writing – Original Draft: Preparing the initial manuscript and developing its scholarly arguments.
  • Writing – Review and Editing: Critically reviewing, revising, and improving the intellectual and academic content of the manuscript.
  • Supervision: Providing substantive academic guidance and intellectual oversight of the research.
  • Project Administration: Coordinating the research process and managing its administrative requirements.

The use of CRediT contribution descriptions does not replace the journal's authorship criteria. Individuals must still satisfy all four authorship requirements to be recognized as authors.

3. RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE CORRESPONDING AUTHOR

The corresponding author serves as the principal contact between the authors and the Editorial Board throughout manuscript submission, peer review, revision, and publication. The corresponding author is responsible for coordinating communication and ensuring that all authors comply with the journal's submission and publication requirements.

The corresponding author must:

  • Ensure that every listed author satisfies the authorship criteria established by Malaqbi Law Review.
  • Confirm that all authors have reviewed and approved the submitted manuscript and have agreed to its submission to the journal.
  • Provide complete and accurate author information, including full names without academic titles, institutional affiliations, institutional addresses, and active email addresses.
  • Ensure that individual author contributions are accurately described and appropriately acknowledged.
  • Ensure that all relevant declarations are provided, including conflicts of interest, funding sources, research ethics approvals, and other applicable ethical disclosures.
  • Communicate editorial decisions, reviewer comments, and revision requirements to all co-authors.
  • Coordinate manuscript revisions and obtain the agreement of all co-authors before submitting revised and final versions.
  • Ensure that all co-authors remain informed of the manuscript's editorial and publication status.

The corresponding author must not independently add, remove, or modify author information without the knowledge and agreement of the other affected authors and approval from the Editorial Board where required.

4. AUTHOR ORDER AND CHANGES IN AUTHORSHIP

The order of authors should be determined collectively by all contributors based on the nature and extent of their respective intellectual contributions to the research. All authors must agree on the final order before manuscript submission.

Malaqbi Law Review does not recognize academic rank, institutional seniority, or professional position as sufficient justification for determining author order. The arrangement should reflect the actual contributions made by each individual.

Any request to add, remove, or rearrange authors after manuscript submission must be accompanied by a written explanation and the agreement of all authors concerned, including individuals being added or removed.

Such requests must be submitted to the Editorial Board for consideration and approval. The journal may request additional supporting documentation when necessary to verify the legitimacy of the proposed changes.

Changes in authorship must not be used to misrepresent individual contributions, conceal inappropriate authorship practices, or circumvent the journal's authorship requirements.

5. CONTRIBUTORS WHO DO NOT QUALIFY FOR AUTHORSHIP

Individuals whose contributions do not satisfy all four authorship criteria should not be listed as authors. Nevertheless, their assistance may be appropriately recognized in the Acknowledgments section, provided that their permission has been obtained.

Examples of contributions that do not independently justify authorship include:

  • Providing financial support or research funding without substantial intellectual involvement.
  • Offering general supervision, institutional endorsement, or administrative assistance.
  • Providing technical support, document preparation, or data entry without substantial research involvement.
  • Performing proofreading, language editing, translation, or formatting services.
  • Providing access to legal documents, research locations, institutions, or research participants without contributing substantially to the intellectual development of the manuscript.
  • Providing general academic advice without participating in the research design, manuscript preparation, or critical intellectual revision.

Malaqbi Law Review strictly discourages the following inappropriate authorship practices:

  • Guest or Honorary Authorship: Listing individuals as authors despite their failure to meet the established authorship criteria, often due to academic position, reputation, or institutional influence.
  • Gift Authorship: Granting authorship as a form of personal or professional favor without a legitimate intellectual contribution.
  • Ghost Authorship: Excluding individuals who have made substantial contributions to the research or manuscript from the official author list.

For manuscripts developed from undergraduate theses, master's theses, or doctoral dissertations, supervisors and academic advisors may be recognized as co-authors only when their contributions fulfill all the journal's authorship requirements.

6. ETHICAL COMPLIANCE AND AUTHORSHIP DISPUTES

All authors share responsibility for maintaining the accuracy, originality, and integrity of their submitted and published scholarly work. Authors are expected to resolve questions concerning authorship eligibility, contribution statements, and author attribution through transparent and responsible communication.

When an authorship dispute cannot be resolved among the individuals concerned, the Editorial Board may request supporting explanations and refer the matter to the relevant institution or research organization for further examination.

Where necessary, the journal may temporarily suspend editorial processing or publication of the manuscript until the dispute has been appropriately addressed. Any further editorial action will be determined in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies.

Authors are also required to comply with the journal's requirements concerning originality, research ethics, conflicts of interest, and responsible scholarly communication. Submission of a manuscript constitutes confirmation that the authorship information and contribution declarations are accurate and complete.

7. USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN AUTHORSHIP

Artificial intelligence (AI) systems and AI-assisted technologies, including generative AI applications and large language models, cannot be recognized as authors or co-authors of manuscripts submitted to Malaqbi Law Review. Such systems cannot independently assume academic responsibility, provide ethical accountability, or take responsibility for the integrity of published scholarly work.

In accordance with the journal's AI Use Policy, AI tools may only be used for limited, non-substantive assistance, such as grammar checking, spelling correction, language refinement, and improving readability. AI tools must not replace the authors' intellectual contributions or be used to generate, fabricate, manipulate, or alter research data, findings, analytical results, references, citations, legal materials, substantive legal arguments, or research conclusions.

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, proper attribution, and integrity of all manuscript content, including material that has received permitted AI-assisted language editing. Any permitted use of AI must be handled transparently and in accordance with the journal's separate AI Use Policy.

For further information, authors are required to consult the following policy:

Malaqbi Law Review – AI Use Policy

By submitting a manuscript to Malaqbi Law Review, all authors confirm that their authorship information is accurate, their contributions have been appropriately represented, and they accept collective responsibility for the scholarly and ethical integrity of the submitted work.